Thursday, September 29, 2011

Too much of nothing

Is more placebo better?

A friend of mine pointed me to the above TED talk, by Ben Goldacre. It's a entertaining presentation with lots of interesting content, although Goldacre's discussion of the placebo effect—"one of the most fascinating things in the whole of medicine" (6:32)—is a little weak. At 6:47, he says:

We know for example that two sugar pills a day are a more effective treatment for getting rid of gastric ulcers than one sugar pill a day. Two sugar pills a day beats one pill a day. And that's an outrageous and ridiculous finding, but it's true.
Notice that the claim is not about pain, but about actually healing the ulcers.

The source of this claim is apparently a 1999 study by de Craen and co-authors titled "Placebo effect in the treatment of duodenal ulcer" [free full text/pdf]. It's a systematic review based on 79 randomized trials comparing various drugs to placebo, taken either four times a day or twice a day depending on the study. (Note that Goldacre refers to twice a day versus once a day; I'm uncertain of the reason for the difference.) From each trial, the authors extracted the results in the placebo group only, obtaining the following results:

The pooled 4 week healing rate of the 51 trials with a four times a day regimen was 44.2% (805 of 1821 patients) compared with 36.2% (545 of 1504 patients) in the 28 trials with a twice a day regimen
This 8% difference was statistically significant, and remained so even when several different statistical models were used.

However, the authors are up-front about a key limitation of the study: "We realize that the comparison was based on nonrandomized data." Even though the data were obtained from randomized trials, none of the trials individually compared a four-times-a-day placebo regimen to a twice-a-day placebo regimen, so the analysis is a nonrandomized comparison. What if there were important differences between the patients, the study procedures, or the overall medical care provided in the four-times-a-day trials and the two-times-a-day trials? The authors discuss various attempts to adjust for gender, age, smoking, and type of comparator drug, but report that this made little difference. But they acknowledge that:

Although we adjusted for a number of possible confounders, we can not rule out that in this nonrandomized comparison the observed difference was caused by some unrecognized confounding factor or factors.
The strength of a randomized comparison is that important differences between groups are unlikely—even when it comes to unrecognized factors. Although the authors go on to consider other possible biases, their bottom line is:
... we speculate that the difference between regimens was induced by the difference in frequency of placebo administration.
These results of this study are intriguing, but they're hardly definitive.

Labels:

Bookmark and Share

31 Comments:

Anonymous The Best Colleges said...

We wanted to let you know that your blog was included in our list of the top 50 statistics blogs of 2011. Our goal was to highlight blogs that students and prospective students will find useful and interesting in their exploration of the field.

You can view the entire list at http://www.thebestcolleges.org/best-statistics-blogs/

Congratulations!

12:29 PM, October 10, 2011  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Research Disguised as Intervention

http://research-disguised-as-intervention.blogspot.com/

3:49 AM, October 31, 2011  
Blogger applepie 894 said...

Thank you for such a nice detailed post.

รับแทงบอล
sbobet mobile
royal1688
ทางเข้า maxbet

2:07 AM, November 29, 2017  
Blogger Spack Jarrow said...

Thank you so much.
แทงบอล sbobet หวยออนไลน์ royal1688 ทางเข้า maxbet

10:14 PM, December 05, 2017  
Blogger sahmon said...

I like all your posts. You are really good...


goldenslot

goldenslot

สมัครแทงบอล

2:03 AM, December 22, 2017  
Blogger Mozmee007 said...

Great articles are interesting and informative.


แทงบอล sbobet
sbobet mobile
รับแทงบอล

11:53 PM, December 24, 2017  
Blogger ประภัสสร รัตนน์ said...

Thanks for the info And I hope to read this good article again.
โปรแกรมบอล
โปรแกรมบอลวันนี้
ดูบอลออนไลน์
ดููบอลสด

10:07 PM, January 05, 2018  
Blogger kfc55 said...

I like to read your blog post with great information. I get a good idea from this wonderful blog.
ทางเข้า maxbet
m8bet
สมัคร sbobet

5:01 AM, January 17, 2018  
Blogger boonmee said...

Thanks for the info And I hope to read this good article again.

m8bet

สมัคร sbobet

สมัคร maxbet

11:47 PM, January 27, 2018  
Blogger Toni444 said...

Yes my friend I think it's a great story and it's really scary. Wow, I like it a lot.



m8bet

m8bet

บาคาร่า

4:44 AM, January 29, 2018  
Blogger mozav007 said...

I like to read your blog post with great information.

ทางเข้า maxbet
m8bet
สมัคร sbobet

1:24 AM, February 01, 2018  
Blogger Lauren john said...

Hello my name is Lauren i'm from USA i want to testify of a great and powerful spell caster my husband left me and the kids for 2 weeks when i called him he didn't pick up when he came back home the 3rd week he told me he wanted a divorce i was so sad i cried all night he left again i was so lonely the next day i was searching for something online when i found a spell caster called Priest Ade who have helped so many people with their problems so i contacted him with my problems he told me it will take 24hrs and my husband will be back to me i did every thing he told me to do and the next day my husband came back kneeling and begging he canceled the divorce we are now happy together Priest Ade can help you too Email him at

ancientspiritspellcast@yahoo.com or ancientspiritspellcast@gmail.com

Blogs: https://relationshipspell.blogspot.com

Website http://ancientspiritspellcast.website2.me

WhatsApp +2347059715465

2:06 AM, July 27, 2018  
Blogger Lauren john said...

Hello my name is Lauren i'm from USA i want to testify of a great and powerful spell caster my husband left me and the kids for 2 weeks when i called him he didn't pick up when he came back home the 3rd week he told me he wanted a divorce i was so sad i cried all night he left again i was so lonely the next day i was searching for something online when i found a spell caster called Priest Ade who have helped so many people with their problems so i contacted him with my problems he told me it will take 24hrs and my husband will be back to me i did every thing he told me to do and the next day my husband came back kneeling and begging he canceled the divorce we are now happy together Priest Ade can help you too Email him at

ancientspiritspellcast@yahoo.com or ancientspiritspellcast@gmail.com

Blogs: https://relationshipspell.blogspot.com

Website http://ancientspiritspellcast.website2.me

WhatsApp +2347059715465

2:06 AM, July 27, 2018  
Blogger Lauren john said...

Hello my name is Lauren i'm from USA i want to testify of a great and powerful spell caster my husband left me and the kids for 2 weeks when i called him he didn't pick up when he came back home the 3rd week he told me he wanted a divorce i was so sad i cried all night he left again i was so lonely the next day i was searching for something online when i found a spell caster called Priest Ade who have helped so many people with their problems so i contacted him with my problems he told me it will take 24hrs and my husband will be back to me i did every thing he told me to do and the next day my husband came back kneeling and begging he canceled the divorce we are now happy together Priest Ade can help you too Email him at

ancientspiritspellcast@yahoo.com or ancientspiritspellcast@gmail.com

Blogs: https://relationshipspell.blogspot.com

Website http://ancientspiritspellcast.website2.me

WhatsApp +2347059715465

2:06 AM, July 27, 2018  
Blogger Lauren john said...

Hello my name is Lauren i'm from USA i want to testify of a great and powerful spell caster my husband left me and the kids for 2 weeks when i called him he didn't pick up when he came back home the 3rd week he told me he wanted a divorce i was so sad i cried all night he left again i was so lonely the next day i was searching for something online when i found a spell caster called Priest Ade who have helped so many people with their problems so i contacted him with my problems he told me it will take 24hrs and my husband will be back to me i did every thing he told me to do and the next day my husband came back kneeling and begging he canceled the divorce we are now happy together Priest Ade can help you too Email him at

ancientspiritspellcast@yahoo.com or ancientspiritspellcast@gmail.com

Blogs: https://relationshipspell.blogspot.com

Website http://ancientspiritspellcast.website2.me

WhatsApp +2347059715465

2:06 AM, July 27, 2018  
Blogger Lauren john said...

Hello my name is Lauren i'm from USA i want to testify of a great and powerful spell caster my husband left me and the kids for 2 weeks when i called him he didn't pick up when he came back home the 3rd week he told me he wanted a divorce i was so sad i cried all night he left again i was so lonely the next day i was searching for something online when i found a spell caster called Priest Ade who have helped so many people with their problems so i contacted him with my problems he told me it will take 24hrs and my husband will be back to me i did every thing he told me to do and the next day my husband came back kneeling and begging he canceled the divorce we are now happy together Priest Ade can help you too Email him at

ancientspiritspellcast@yahoo.com or ancientspiritspellcast@gmail.com

Blogs: https://relationshipspell.blogspot.com

Website http://ancientspiritspellcast.website2.me

WhatsApp +2347059715465

2:07 AM, July 27, 2018  
Blogger Javis Bot said...

Thank you for sharing such great information. It is informative, can you help me in finding out more detail on แทงบอล ,

2:38 PM, August 16, 2018  
Blogger กวิน ฮา said...

thank for good sharing,....

โกลเด้นสล็อต
goldenslot
golden slot
ทางเข้า goldenslot
goldenslot online

12:12 AM, August 17, 2018  
Blogger Nadeem Malik said...

hi, nice information is given in this blog. Thanks for sharing this type of information, it is so useful for me. nice work keep it up.
Business visa provider in Delhi

1:10 AM, August 18, 2018  
Blogger Akash Thakur said...

nice topic which you have choose.
second is, the information which you have provided is better then other blog.
so nice work keep it up. And thanks for sharing.
PVC Door Manufacturers in Hubli

2:44 AM, August 18, 2018  
Blogger Pankaj Singh said...

Nice blog, thank you so much for sharing this. I’m really impressed with this. Visit for
Bulletproof VPS

7:10 AM, August 30, 2018  
Blogger Pankaj Singh said...

Nice blog, thank you so much for sharing this. I’m really impressed with this. Visit for
Best Server Management Company

7:12 AM, August 30, 2018  
Blogger Darryl Duncan said...

Hello everyone, I must start by saying that I didn’t go into marriage with expectation that it will fail after 8 years. I and my spouse where not compassionate to ourselves. Trying to work out my marriage was self-defeating, we don’t really know why we no longer find ourselves attractive anymore. All we secretly thought was divorce, we couldn’t agree or communicate anymore, it was emotionally difficult moments when we face each other in the bedroom.
I know that a phycologist might not be able to help me go through divorce because it has never worked for me. Divorcing could traumatize our kids, I can’t let them be emotionally crippled.
I remember my grandmother once told me that not issues can be resolved physically, I should try solving some issues spiritually through a well-known spiritual doctor.
I can provide evidence that my life and marriage got more better and interesting with so much love and fulfilled promises after Dr. Wakina lighted up our fire with a magnificent love spell with the aid of dr.wakinalovetemple@gmail.com.
The spell work I never regarded rewrote my story. I’m touched beyond words, thanks Dr. Wakina.

11:06 AM, August 30, 2018  
Blogger ิbell noon said...

บาคาร่า

2:28 AM, August 31, 2018  
Blogger Luisa Ryan said...

My name is Luisa Ryan from Germany, I and my husband have been married for 10 years and we have 3 lovely kids, my husband was always busy with work but when ever it is weekend he always take me and our kids out for dinner and sometime we go shopping together because the kids like to buy things, our family was happy until my husband went on a business trip, when he came back he started acting strange he didn't have time for me and the kids anymore, last month he told me that he is tired of our marriage that he want a divorce at first I thought he was joking until he packed out of the house leaving me and the kids alone, I was heartbroken I couldn't eat for days I cried and cried and the kid were always asking for their dad and I do lied to them, I couldn't take it anymore I decided to search on how to get him back I came across Dr Great email I didn't want to email him at first but knowing am losing my husband I emailed him and explained my problem to him, he replied my mail and told me that he will help me it's will take 24 hrs to cast the spell, after he finished casting the spell he told me my husband will soon be back, few hours later my husband came back home begging I forgive him now we are living happily together, all thanks to Dr Great for saving my marriage. If your husband or wife left you and you want him or her back the right man to bring them back is Dr Great he is a good man he is a messager send by God to help us in time of problems he can put a stop to your problem email him at infinitylovespell@gmail.com or infinitylovespell@yahoo.com
WhatsApp him +2348118829899
http://luisaryan35.blogspot.com/

5:01 AM, September 11, 2018  
Blogger Luisa Ryan said...

My name is Luisa Ryan from Germany, I and my husband have been married for 10 years and we have 3 lovely kids, my husband was always busy with work but when ever it is weekend he always take me and our kids out for dinner and sometime we go shopping together because the kids like to buy things, our family was happy until my husband went on a business trip, when he came back he started acting strange he didn't have time for me and the kids anymore, last month he told me that he is tired of our marriage that he want a divorce at first I thought he was joking until he packed out of the house leaving me and the kids alone, I was heartbroken I couldn't eat for days I cried and cried and the kid were always asking for their dad and I do lied to them, I couldn't take it anymore I decided to search on how to get him back I came across Dr Great email I didn't want to email him at first but knowing am losing my husband I emailed him and explained my problem to him, he replied my mail and told me that he will help me it's will take 24 hrs to cast the spell, after he finished casting the spell he told me my husband will soon be back, few hours later my husband came back home begging I forgive him now we are living happily together, all thanks to Dr Great for saving my marriage. If your husband or wife left you and you want him or her back the right man to bring them back is Dr Great he is a good man he is a messager send by God to help us in time of problems he can put a stop to your problem email him at infinitylovespell@gmail.com or infinitylovespell@yahoo.com
WhatsApp him +2348118829899
http://luisaryan35.blogspot.com/

5:02 AM, September 11, 2018  
Blogger Skye Cecil said...

Not certain where to begin, I was overwhelmed lately trying to get out of a funk situation in a relationship. My fiancé was a whole other story. He was downright hurtful and ungrateful; his life and belongings were in shambles. He was someone addicted to drugs and women. He liked hiding behind excuses, giving me reasons to live a reckless life.
But we share great bond, we can’t let go because we aren’t perfect after all.
One thing we needed was someone or a spell doctor that will place himself in our spot to cure or tell us how easy it is to maintain or build a relationship surrounded by true love and healthy living.
However, the reality of my story is that Dr. Wakina via (dr.wakinalovetemple@gmail.com) with a succeeding love spell made sure none of my pipe dreams at the expenses of a broken heart become reality.

12:11 PM, September 11, 2018  
Blogger Kaitlyn Houston said...

Hello everyone i am happy to spread my testimony of a strong spell caster called Dr Great. I'm Kaitlyn Houston and i live in USA, my husband and i had a little fight because of that he wanted to divorce me i was so afraid to lose him because i love him very much so i search online for help and i saw alot of people's testimonies on how Dr Great help them and came out with positive results like Divorces, Cancers, lotteries, fertilities and others. So i emailed him and told him my problem and he told me what to do and I did it as he instructed, 24 hours later he told me he is done with the spell and my husband will no longer divorce me and when my husband came back from work he told me he won't divorce me anymore he said he didn't know what came over him that he is sorry I was so happy and I thank Dr Great for his help If you need Dr Great help email him at infinitylovespell@gmail.com or infinitylovespell@yahoo.com my page https://kaitlynhouston19.blogspot.com you can also add him on WhatsApp +2348118829899 and he will put an end to your problem

1:16 AM, September 12, 2018  
Blogger lol CTV said...

ป๊อกเด้ง

5:19 AM, September 14, 2018  
Blogger Kaitlyn Houston said...

Hello everyone i am happy to spread my testimony of a strong spell caster called Dr Great. I'm Kaitlyn Houston and i live in USA, my husband and i had a little fight because of that he wanted to divorce me i was so afraid to lose him because i love him very much so i search online for help and i saw alot of people's testimonies on how Dr Great help them and came out with positive results like Divorces, Cancers, lotteries, fertilities and others. So i emailed him and told him my problem and he told me what to do and I did it as he instructed, 24 hours later he told me he is done with the spell and my husband will no longer divorce me and when my husband came back from work he told me he won't divorce me anymore he said he didn't know what came over him that he is sorry I was so happy and I thank Dr Great for his help If you need Dr Great help email him at infinitylovespell@gmail.com or infinitylovespell@yahoo.com my page https://kaitlynhouston19.blogspot.com you can also add him on WhatsApp +2348118829899 and he will put an end to your problem

3:27 AM, September 19, 2018  
Blogger Meentosys Pvt Ltd said...

nice post, website designing services is taken instead casually through maximum companies in India, even in the capital city, New Delhi. while the commercial ventures far and extensive are more and more adopting online identity, most fail to go for it with proper focus on greatest utilization state the web platform. each commercial venture that goes online expects enhanced business prospects just by going online, realizing little the difference between a website for the heck state it and a good website development. website designing company in Delhi

6:37 AM, September 19, 2018  

Post a Comment

<< Home